Return to MSUcares Home Page

Malathion Fate in Water and Catfish

Technical Bulletin 225 -- December 1999 -- Printable .pdf version

 

Table 1. Concentration (ppb) of malathion in water from tanks dosed with various levels of malathion and sampled at various intervals after dosing.

Sample time1

Concentration applied to water (ppb)2

60

12

2.4

0.48

0 day after dosing

53.00 a

11.100 a

2.30a

0.50 a

1 day after dosing

1.40 b

0.260 b

0.07 b

0.00 b3

2 days after dosing

0.36 b

0.072 b

0.00 b

0.00 b

3 days after dosing

0.00 b

0.000 b

0.00 b

0.00 b

5 days after dosing

NA

NA

NA

NA

7 days after dosing

NA

NA

NA

NA

14 days after dosing

NA

NA

NA

NA

Log intercept (intercept)

3.61 (37.0)

2.15 (8.61)

1.02 (2.76)

0.34 (1.40)

Log slope (per day)4

-2.92 A

-1.83 AB

-0.88 BC

-0.30 C

Slope (probability of F)5

0.0002

0.0036

0.0865

0.5264

Predicted day = 0.02 ppb

2.42

2.21

2.10

1.91

R2

0.92

0.84

0.82

0.78

1Concentrations at 0 day are averages of three sample analyses. All other concentrations are based on analysis of one composite sample for the three-replicate experiment. The 0-day sample was taken approximately 15 minutes after dosing. The study was conducted in fiberglass tanks.
2Means within a column followed by the same lowercase letter are not significantly different (LSD, p = 0.05).
30.00 = none detected (quantification limit = 0.02 ppb).
4Slopes followed by the same uppercase letter in this row are not significantly different (F, p < 0.05). Regression equation: log (concentration) = log (intercept) + Bi log (time), where Bi = log (slope).
5F-test of slope where Ho is slope = 0.

 

Table 2. Concentrations (ppb) of malathion in water from tanks with fish and tanks without fish dosed with 46 ppb malathion.

Sample time

 No fish  

 Fish2  

 Mean3

0 hour after dosing  

 33.0  

 40.0  

 36.5a

6 hours after dosing  

 17.0  

 13.0  

 15.0b

24 hours after dosing  

 7.7  

 1.3  

 4.5bc

48 hours after dosing  

 1.4  

 0.0  

 0.7c

Log intercept (intercept)  

 3.76 (42.95)  

 3.97 (52.98)

Log slope (per hour)4  

 -0.62 A  

 -0.96A

Slope (probability of F)5  

 0.0734  

 0.0244

Predicted hour = 0.02 ppb  

 416.7  

 60.2

R2  

 0.86  

 0.95

1The 0-hour sample was taken approximately 15 minutes after dosing. Water pH was 8.9. This study was conducted in fiberglass tanks.
20.0 = none detected (quantification limit = 0.02 ppb)
3Means followed by the same lowercase letter in this column are not significantly different (LSD, p = 0.05).
4Slopes followed by the same uppercase letter in this row are not significantly different (F, p < 0.05). Regression equation: log (concentration) = log (intercept) + Bi log (time), where Bi = log (slope).
5F-test of slope (Ho: slope = 0).

 

Table 3. Concentrations (ppb) of malathion in pH 7.0 and 8.5 well water dosed with 42 ppb malathion.1

Sample time2  

 pH 7.0  

 pH 8.5  

 Means3

0 hour after dosing  

 41.0  

 42.0  

 41.5 a

6 hours after dosing  

 32.0  

 24.0  

 28.0 ab

24 hours after dosing  

 23.0  

 8.6  

 15.8 bc

48 hours after dosing  

 5.2  

 1.1  

 3.2 c

 

 

 

 

Log intercept (intercept)  

 3.81 (45.2)  

 3.69 (40.1)

 

Log slope (per hour)4  

 -0.039 A  

 -0.061 B

 

Slope (probability of F)5  

 0.0014  

 0.0002

 

Predicted hour = 0.02 ppb  

 98.3  

 59.9

 

R2  

 0.95  

 0.99

 

1Water was held in glass containers with no fish. The unadjusted pH was 8.5, and the adjusted pH was 7.0.
2The 0-hour sample was taken approximately 15 minutes after dosing.
3Means followed by the same letter in this column are not significantly different (LSD, p = 0.05).
4Slopes not followed by the same uppercase letter in this row are significantly different (F, p = 0.03). Regression equation: log (concentration) = log (intercept) + Bi (time), where Bi = log (slope).
5F-test of slope where Ho is slope = 0.

 

Table 4. Concentrations (ppb) of malathion in pH 7.0 and 8.9 deionized distilled water in glass containers dosed with 12 or 60 ppb malathion.

Sample time1

Water pH/initial malathion concentration (ppb)

 

 7.0/12

7.0/60

8.9/60

Means2

0 hour after dosing

9.3

57.0

57.0

41.1a

1 hour after dosing

7.9

49.0

44.0

33.6ab

2 hours after dosing

12.0

56.0

40.0

36.0ab

4 hours after dosing

11.0

54.0

&emdash;

21.7b

8 hours after dosing

13.0

53.0

38.0

34.7ab

24 hours after dosing

12.0

59.0

36.0

35.7ab

48 hours after dosing

13.0

56.0

34.0

34.3ab

 

 

 

 

 

Log intercept (intercept)

2.32 (10.21)

3.99 (54.27)

3.27 (26.15)

 

Log slope (per hour)3

0.091 A

0.015 A

0.040 A

 

Slope (probability of F)4

0.0568

0.4361

0.9340

 

R2

0.55

0.13

0.002

 

1The 0-hour sample was approximately 15 minutes after dosing.
2
Means followed by the same lowercase letter in this column are not significantly different (LSD, p = 0.05).
3
Slopes followed by the same uppercase letter in this row are not significantly different (F, p < 0.05). Regression equation: log (concentration) = log (intercept) + Bi log (time), where Bi = log (slope).
4
F-test of slope (Ho: slope = 0).

 

Table 5. Concentrations (ppb) of malathion in deionized distilled water, pond water, and pond water and sediment in glass containers dosed with 51 ppb malathion.1

Sample time2  

 Laboratory water (pH 7.0)  

  Pond water
(pH 7.85)  

   Pond water sediment
(pH 7.85)  

 Means3  

0 hour after dosing  

 45.0  

 49.0  

 38.0  

 44.0 a

6 hours after dosing  

 33.0  

 34.0  

 28.0  

 31.7 b

24 hours after dosing  

 33.0  

 29.0  

 23.0  

 28.3 b

48 hours after dosing  

 27.0  

 21.0  

 16.0  

 21.3 c

 

 

 

 

 

Lop intercept (intercept)  

 3.81 (45.15)  

 3.93 (50.91)  

 3.70 (40.45)  

 

Log slope (per hour)4  

 -0.11 A  

 -0.19 A  

 -0.20 A  

 

Slope (probability of F)5  

 0.0499  

 0.0239  

 0.0369  

 

R2  

 0.90  

 0.95  

 0.93  

 

1Pond water and pond water and sediment samples came from earthen ponds containing channel catfish at the National Warmwater Aquaculture Center in Stoneville, MS.
2The 0-hour sample was approximately 15 minutes after dosing.
3Means followed by the same lowercase letter in this column are not significantly different (LSD, p = 0.05).
4Slopes followed by the same uppercase letter in this row are not significantly different (F, p = 0.05). Regression equation: log (concentration) = log (intercept) + Bi log (time),where Bi = log (slope).
5F-test of slope (Ho: slope = 0).

 

Table 6. Concentrations of malathion in pond water dosed with 35 ppb malathion (pond B).1

Sample time   

 Average malathion concentration (ppb)2 3

1 hour after dosing   

 7.7 a

6 hours after dosing   

 4.1 b

22 hours after dosing   

 1.2 c

48 hours after dosing   

 0.0 c

72 hours after dosing   

 0.0 c

168 hours after dosing 0.0 c

 

 

Log intercept (intercept)   

 2.54 (12.69)

Log slope (per hour)   

 -0.55

Slope (probability of F)4   

 0.0001

Predicted hour = 0.02 ppb   

 100.23

R2   

 0.93

1Water samples came from earthen ponds containing channel catfish at the National Warmwater Aquaculture Center in Stoneville, MS. Water pH was 7.9 at the time of dosing, which was approximately 10 a.m. Pond B was one of two ponds used in this study; it was sampled at five sites.
2Means followed by the same letter are not significantly different (LSD, p = 0.05).
30.0 = None detected (quantification limit = 0.02 ppb).
4F-test of slope (Ho: slope = 0). Regression equation: log (concentration) = log (intercept) + Bi log (time), where Bi = log (slope).

 

Table 7. Concentrations of malathion in pond water dosed with 82 ppb malathion (pond A).1

Sample time   

 Average malathion concentration (ppb)2 3

1 hour after dosing   

 9.20 a

17 hours after dosing   

 10.50 a

48 hours after dosing   

 1.50 b

72 hours after dosing   

 0.49 b

168 hours after dosing   

 0.00 b

 

 

Log intercept (intercept)   

 2.98 (19.67)

Log slope (per hour)   

-0.55

Slope (probability of F)4   

 0.0722

Predicted hour = 0.02 ppb   

 218.24

R2   

 0.71

1Water samples came from earthen ponds containing channel catfish at the National Warmwater Aquaculture Center in Stoneville, MS. Water pH was 8.3 at the time of dosing, which was approximately 3:30 p.m. Pond A was one of two ponds used in this study; it was sampled at five sites.
2Means followed by the same letter are not significantly different (LSD, p = 0.05).
30.0 = None detected (quantification limit = 0.02 ppb).
4F-test of slope (Ho: slope = 0). Regression equation: log (concentration) = log (intercept) + Bi log (time), where Bi = log (slope).

 

Table 8. Malathion residues in channel catfish fillet and carcass samples taken at various times after dosing from pond B.1

Sample time   

 Type sample analyzed2   

   

Carcass   

 Fillet

6 hours after dosing   

 0.03   

 0.0

24 hours after dosing   

 0.0   

 0.0

48 hours after dosing   

 0.0   

 0.0

72 hours after dosing   

 0.0   

 0.0

168 hours after dosing   

 0.0   

 NA

1Fish samples were taken from earthen ponds at the National Warmwater Aquaculture Center in Stoneville, MS. This pond was one of two used in the study; it was dosed with 35 ppb malathion.
2No statistical analysis.
30.0 = None detected (quantification limit = 0.02 ppm).

 

Table 9. Malathion residues in channel catfish fillet and carcass samples taken at various times after dosing from pond A.1

Sample time   

 Type sample analyzed2   

   

Carcass   

 Fillet

Pretreatment   

 0.03   

 0.0

17 hours after dosing   

 0.04   

 0.0

48 hours after dosing   

 0.0   

 0.0

72 hours after dosing   

 NA5   

 0.0

168 hours after dosing   

 NA   

 0.0

1Fish samples were taken from earthen ponds at the National Warmwater Aquaculture Center in Stoneville, MS. This pond was one of two used in the study; it was dosed with 82 ppb malathion
2No statistical analysis.
30.0 = None detected (quantification limit = 0.02 ppm).
4Trace detected < 0.01 ppm (quantification limit = 0.02 ppm).
5NA = Not analyzed.

 

A black line that separates the body text from footer information