Producing Fish and Shellfish in Dredged Material Containment AreasContentsIntroduction AcknowledgementsThe illustrations are reproduced with the permission of the artist, Mr. John Norton, Annapolis, MD. This work was sponsored in part by the NOAA/National Sea Grant College Program, U.S. Department of Commerce, under Grant Number NA90AA-D-SG802, through the Mississippi-Alabama Sea Grant Consortium. Supporting funds for this grant were provided by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers Waterways Experiment Station, Vicksburg, MS. The U.S. Government and the Mississippi-Alabama Sea Grant Consortium are authorized to produce and distribute reprints for governmental purposes notwithstanding any copyright notation that may appear within. This is Mississippi-Alabama Sea Grant Program Publication No. MASGP 011. By IntroductionMost people think that aquaculture, the raising of fish, shrimp, or shellfish in fresh or salt water, is one of the newer forms of agriculture. On the contrary, fish farming is an ancient practice. The Romans, Egyptians, Chinese, and even the Mayan Indians farmed fish for food at least 4,000 years ago. Ponds were constructed and fish were raised in much the same way as they are today. Commercial production and marketing of fish has been economically successful in many parts of the United States. Photos of ponds packed with fish, news reports of successful aquaculture operations, and television shows on the "blue revolution" have sparked the interest of many people. Fish, shrimp, crawfish, and shellfish (clams, oysters) are excellent animals to raise. Fish and shrimp convert feed to body tissues more efficiently than farm animals; clams, oysters and crawfish don't have to be fed at all. Fish can be intensively cultured in ponds and offer a new, profitable alternative crop to farmers, landowners, and investors. Before jumping into the business, however, consider your decision objectively. Like most other types of farming, fish farming (or shrimp or clam farming, for that matter) is a risky business that requires special knowledge, facilities, and considerations. As a start, let's look at some of the ideas people have about aquaculture. Fiction:
Any marine or aquatic animal can be raised economically. Fiction: Fish
farming is relatively easy. Fiction: Fish
farming is very profitable. Fiction: Fish
farming is a good retirement activity. Fiction: Fishing
is a good background for getting into fish farming. Fiction: I can
easily find a site for a fish pond on my property. The Corps of Engineers and AquacultureThe lack of suitable sites often creates a problem for the aquaculturist. This is where the Corps of Engineers (CE) can play a part. Working with the CE, it may be possible to build ponds that can be used by an aquaculturist for raising fish, crawfish, or other species as well as for the placement of dredged material. The CE is responsible for managing the dredging projects needed to maintain the nation's waterways. A large portion of the dredged material is placed in confined dredged material containment areas or DMCA. Although a DMCA may have a life of up to 50 years, more than 7,000 acres are needed every year for new DMCA. So local dredging sponsors, such as Port Authorities and Navigation Districts, are looking for new ways to acquire land on which to build diked disposal areas. One way is to build ponds that can be used for both aquaculture and dredging. Diked disposal areas share many features with aquaculture ponds: level sites, good foundation soils, water-holding capability, and a water-control structure. Both also have similar discharge and construction permit requirements. The use of dredged material containment areas for both disposal and aquaculture has many benefits. Aquaculturists gain access to good sites and benefit from reduced costs for pond design, engineering, permits, construction, and other site improvements. Land owners benefit from improvements to their property and higher lease fees, and the dredging sponsor obtains the land needed for new DMCA construction. On the other hand, there may be added costs for aquaculturists. A more expensive design may be needed to accommodate both activities. Production may be periodically interrupted or operations modified to allow disposal activities. Pond structures may also need to be rebuilt after large amounts of dredged material have accumulated in the ponds. The actual savings and benefits realized by the aquaculturist will depend on the outcome of negotiations with the CE and the dredging sponsor. The DecisionYour first point of contact in planning any DMCA aquaculture venture is the Corps of Engineers District Office in your area. To be successful, a DMCA aquaculture project requires a CE dredging project in the area, a need for additional land for DMCA, CE interest in the project, and that the aquaculture operation be compatible with the dredging project's disposal needs. There are some important points to keep in mind when considering aquaculture in a confined disposal area. Although most dredging operations involve clean sediments, it is important to check the quality of material to be placed on a site. Remember, the CE and the dredging sponsor will be interested only if they, too, can benefit from the project. The CE demonstrated the feasibility of commercial aquaculture in DMCA as an incentive for landowners to make additional sites available for the construction of new disposal areas. There is little interest in the CE for refitting existing DMCA for aquaculture without additional sites becoming available for new disposal areas. Once the feasibility of a DMCA aquaculture venture is established, you must make some serious planning decisions. Detailed planning is essential before you make any large capital investment. Planning includes a detailed evaluation of the biological, economic, and legal feasibility of raising a particular species. To help you determine if DMCA aquaculture is possible in your particular situation, a checklist of important points to consider is provided below. It doesn't cover all of the possibilities, but it does cover most of the important considerations. Answering "yes" to most of the questions does not necessarily mean success, just as answering "no" does not mean failure. Although the questions refer to "fish," the term includes shrimp, crawfish, and shellfish (clams and oysters) as well. ChecklistManagement( ) Do you have a suitable
pond site? Marketing( ) Do you know of an
established market for your fish? Physical Factors( ) Is the site suitable
for construction of a confined disposal area? Production( ) Is there electrical
power available to the site? RisksAre you prepared to
handle these problems? The InvestmentYour first step should be evaluating the economic feasibility of the project. The economic success of a DMCA aquaculture venture will depend, in part, on the species cultured, on the site selected, and on how dredging operations will affect production. Equally important are the operators' skills in administration, farm management, and marketing. The amount of investment required will vary with the species, the management and production systems selected, and other factors. Develop possible production plans to help you decide on species and production system choices. The agreements negotiated with the dredging sponsor and the CE will also affect the amount of investment needed for design and construction and may affect the revenue as well. The following is a list of costs common to most fish, crawfish, and shrimp farms. Use this list to get familiar with the type of costs you will incur and to determine the approximate costs for your situation. Capital and Fixed Costs
Operating Costs
* Negotiate cost with CE and dredging sponsor Financing for aquaculture is difficult to obtain outside of major catfish and crawfish producing areas. The most successful way to get financing is to use personal funds to operate a pilot project for several years. Then you can use the financial records from your operation as the foundation for a business plan and loan proposal to a bank. Information on how to produce an agriculture business plan is available from the Extension Service in your area. Your local banks are the contacts for Small Business Administration (SBA), Farmers Home Administration (FmHA), and other agricultural loan programs.
Site and Selection PlanningSelecting a site is the next critical decision. Many aquaculture operations have failed because of poor location. Selecting a site for a dual use DMCA is especially critical because it must be suitable for both material placement and aquaculture. Site selection for DMCA aquaculture is a four-step process. First, you must assess feasibility. The project will be feasible only in locations where there are active dredging projects, where new DMCAs are needed, and where there is a support for the project at the CE District Office and by the local sponsor. Second, the compatibility of the planned aquaculture operations with disposal requirements must be established. You will need information on the dredging project from the CE District office for this. Most important will be frequency and duration of use, sediment type, the presence of any undesirable substances in the sediments, and depth of material placed each time. Remember to consider the entire period the site will be closed to aquaculture for preparation, disposal, and drying, usually about 6 months. Once feasibility and compatibility are established, you can proceed with the actual site evaluation and selection. First, the site must be suitable for the construction and use of DMCA for dredged material placement. The CE District Office will determine this. Only then can the site be evaluated for aquaculture. Much of the engineering information needed for evaluation and planning for aquaculture will be available from the CE District Office. The species selected and the management choice will affect site selection. Look for these characteristics in a potential site during the preliminary survey:
Pond Design and ConstructionPond size, shape, number, levee designs, and other features will vary greatly, depending upon disposal requirements and on the species and management approach you choose. You can negotiate pond features with the CE to arrive at a design suitable for both material disposal and aquaculture. It is important to remember that the ponds will be slowly filled with dredged material. This may require reworking water control structures, drainage, and levees at some later date. Designs for food fish, bait fish, crawfish, and shrimp production are fairly well established. While shellfish (clams and oysters) can be grown in ponds, no preferred pond designs have been developed. The best sources for pond design and engineering information are production manuals, some of which are listed in the "Production" reference section. Pond design assistance is also available from the local offices of the Soil Conservation Service. Cooperative Extension Service or Sea Grant Aquaculture Specialists are available for help as well. The following are some design features to consider in pond construction. These are based on accepted fish farm designs and may apply, with a few changes, in many situations.
Table 1. Time in hours required to pump different volumes of water in acre feet at four different pumping rates.
*
1 acre foot = 325,850 gallons = 1 surface acre that is 1 foot deep. ProductionWhen you get into the production phase of raising fish, crawfish, shrimp, or shellfish, there are many important things you will have to know and remember. This section covers the major species cultured in the United States. Selected references on how to grow these species are included as well. Pond culture involves stocking fish in ponds filled with water. It is a well proven and reliable means of fish production when properly managed. Essentially all species suitable for aquaculture can be grown in standing-water ponds. Ponds have generally proven to be the most economical means of producing fish and the way to get the most fish production per unit of available water. What To Produce?Many types of fish and aquatic animals offer good potential for culture. The discussion that follows is designed to allow you to consider some different species while pointing out the advantages and disadvantages of each. Some of these are included because they appear promising. Other species with poor potential are included only because many people are interested in them.
Golden shiners, fathead minnows, and goldfish are among the most popular bait species and can be produced reliably in ponds. Mud or bull minnows are popular marine bait fish that reproduce naturally and grow well on inexpensive feeds. A series of small flat-bottomed ponds that can be drained, seined, and refilled are needed so buyers can be supplied on a regular basis. If you are considering bait fish production, you need to be aware that you will be competing with large producers. These producers have low production costs and will probably offer their fish at cheap prices if you attempt to compete with them directly. Guidice, J. J., D. L. Gray and M. M. Martin. 1981. Manual for bait fish culture in the south. University of Arkansas Cooperative Extension Service, Little Rock, AR. Strawn, K., P. W. Persbacher, R. Nailon and G. Chamberlain. 1986. Raising mudminnows. Texas A & M Sea Grant Publication 86-506. College Station, TX. Channel Catfish As the most important aquaculture industry in the United States, catfish farming contributes significantly to the economies of many southern states. The channel catfish is preferred over other species of catfish because of its tolerance for handling, good feed conversion, high dress-out percentage, and ease of spawning. Flat-bottomed ponds filled by well water are the ideal situation for catfish production. Jensen, G. L. 1988. Commercial production of farm-raised catfish. Louisiana State University Agricultural Center, Baton Rouge, LA. Lee, J. S. 1981. Commercial catfish farming. Interstate Printers and Publishers, Danville, IL. Wellborn, T. L. 1989a. Catfish farmer's handbook. Mississippi State University Extension Service, Mississippi State, MS. Crawfish Production of crawfish has been economical in Louisiana and Texas, and interest has spread to other states. Large crawfish are prized as a gourmet food item while smaller ones are in demand as bait. Red swamp crawfish are the traditional species to culture. Requirements include relatively flat land with good water holding capacity and enough water to maintain 1 1/2 to 2 feet of water depth. Much labor is needed to harvest and reset traps each day for 4 to 7 months out of the year. Australian crawfish, advertised as "marron" or "freshwater lobster," have been available for several years in this country. A permit to culture this species is needed in most states. To the best of our knowledge, no commercially successful production has been achieved in the U.S. These exotic crawfish are likely to be susceptible to the widespread crawfish fungus plague, to which our native species is resistant. LaCaze, C. 1976. Crawfish farming. Fisheries Bulletin No. 7, Louisiana Department of Wildlife and Fisheries, Baton Rouge, LA. Louisiana Crawfish Farmers' Association. Proceedings of the 13th Annual Meeting, September 10, 1983, Baton Rouge, LA. Hybrid Striped Bass Demand for hybrid striped bass is high, especially on the east coast where the wild catch is declining and pollution problems worry consumers. The cross between white and striped bass has proven to be an excellent fish for pond culture in either fresh or brackish water. There is great interest in pond production of this species. Hodson, R. G., and J. Jarvis. 1990. Raising hybrid striped bass in ponds. UNC Sea Grant Publication 90-05. North Carolina Sea State University, Raleigh, NC. Redfish Redfish can be grown in fresh or salt water. Production was moving to the commercial stage after a series of successful trials. However, market prices are not as attractive as they were several years ago, and the industry has been set back by the apparent susceptibility of redfish to extreme low temperatures. Chamberlain, G. W., R. J. Miget and M. G. Haby, editors. 1990. Red drum aquaculture. Texas A & M Sea Grant Publication 90-603, Galveston, TX. Shrimp Marine penaeid shrimp are a luxury food for which Americans seem to have an ever growing hunger. To help satisfy this hunger, major corporations and private investors have built large shrimp farms in Central America, South America, and Asia, where the tropical climate is favorable. In the continental U.S., South Carolina and Texas have commercial marine shrimp farms. A species of freshwater shrimp, Macrobrachium rosenbergii, grows well at temperatures above 68 °F and salinities of up to eight parts per thousand. Heads are much larger than on marine shrimp and the flesh may be softer than marine shrimp, leading to some marketing difficulties. Because death occurs at temperatures below 50 °F, commercial potential for this species is limited, at best, to the southern states. Chamberlain, G. W., M. G. Haby and R. J. Miget, editors. 1985. Texas shrimp farming manual. Texas Agricultural Extension Service Research and Extension Center, Corpus Christi, TX. New, M. B., and S. Sigholka. 1982. Freshwater prawn farming. FAO Fisheries Technical Paper (225). Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations, Rome, Italy. Sport Fish, Forage Fish Fingerlings, and Tilapia Production of bass, bluegill, hybrid bluegill, and other fingerlings for stocking in private fishing ponds is a proven form of aquaculture that has been practiced for decades. Additional species that can be produced as forage for bass include shad and minnows. Production of these species involves natural spawning of brood stock in ponds, removal of brooders, and rearing of fingerlings in place. Because the production of fingerlings requires much care and skill, it is not recommended for those who have no experience in producing food fish. Originally found in Africa and the Near East, many different species of tilapia have been introduced around the world because of their suitability for aquaculture. Tilapia hybrids have an excellent quality flesh that many people compare to crappie. They are tolerant of poor water quality conditions and grow well on low protein feeds. The leading technical problem in culturing tilapia is that they die when temperatures drop to about 50 °F. Because of this, brood stock or fingerlings must be overwintered in heated indoor tanks or small ponds fed by naturally warm well or spring water. Another serious problem is that many states prohibit or regulate this culture of the species. Dupree, H. K., and J. V. Huner. 1984. Third report to the fish farmers. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Washington, DC. Trout Culture of trout is a major form of aquaculture in Idaho, the Appalachians, and in the central U.S. These cold-water fish generally grow best at water temperatures between 55 and 65 °F and die when temperatures approach 70 °F. In warm-water areas, culture of rainbow trout in ponds during the winter months has been demonstrated. Stevenson, J. P. 1987. Trout farming manual (second edition). Fishing News Books, Ltd. Farnham, Surrey, U.K. Clams and Oysters Shellfish are not currently produced in ponds. However, pond culture of shellfish may be successful under some conditions. Hard clams (East and Gulf coasts) and manila clams (Pacific Northwest) are excellent candidates for aquaculture. Demand for clams is high and prices have increased due to a decline in production from natural stocks in many areas. Aquaculture technology for the hard and manila clams is well established, and profitability appears high. Oysters are attracting commercial aquaculture attention. Oyster hatcheries are well established and growout operations are found on all coasts. Recently, several shrimp farmers have demonstrated the feasibility of raising oysters as a second crop in shrimp ponds. This approach may apply to salt-water fish ponds as well. Castagna, M., and J. N. Kraeuter. 1984. Manual for growing the hard clam Mercenaria. Special report in applied marine science and ocean engineering, Virginia Institute of Marine Sciences Sea Grant Program, Gloucester Point, VA. Magoon, C., and R. Vining. 1980. Introduction to shellfish aquaculture in the Puget Sound region. Washington Department of Natural Resources Handbook, Olympia, WA.
Water Quality
StockingWhile production techniques differ with the species and the management system you choose, some examples of how to calculate important production variables are illustrated below. Before stocking the pond, weigh and sample-count the stock so you can determine the number actually being stocked. To determine number actually stocked, weigh out a sample of fish (1 to 10 lb) and count. Then calculate the total number of fish stocked with this formula: Number of seed stocked = (number in sample X total weight in lb stocked) divided by weight in sample For example: Number of fish in sample
= 266 Thus, number stocked = (266 fish X 85.5 lb) / 5 lb = 4,548 fish To determine the weight of 1,000 fish, weigh and count sample of fish; then: Weight of 1,000 fish = (wt. of fish in sample in lb X 1,000) divided by number of fish in sample Feeding
Adjust amount fed every two weeks by getting a sample of fish from the pond, weighing the sample, and counting the number in the sample. Then use the following formula to calculate the weight of food to feed per acre daily for the next 2 weeks. Weight of feed needed daily per acre = (wt. of sample X no. stocked/acre X % to feed) divided by number in sample Example: Weight of sample = 20
lb Weight of feed needed daily per acre = (20 lb X 4,500 fish X 0.03) / 100 fish = 27 lb feed needed/acre/day Recordkeeping is a must for good management. You can develop your own system or use the forms provided here. Diseases and Treatment
What To Do if Fish Get Sick Know in advance who can provide a diagnosis. Submit sample of sick fish and water sample to the nearest diagnostic laboratory for a quick and accurate diagnosis. Select and ship samples according to instructions available from the laboratory, your county agent, or the Sea Grant Advisory Service. Remember, identify who can provide diagnosis and treatment advice before you have a problem. Make sure you can ship the fish for diagnosis before you have a problem. Be prepared. Control of Undesirable FishThere are two ways to control undesirable fish in ponds:
Fintrol (Antimycin A) -- Legal to use. Used at 1/5 the recommended rate is satisfactory and economical. Use early in the morning when pH is less than 8.5 to reduce cost of treating. Aquatic Weed Control
Daily Feeding Record
Weekly Pond Record
Recap and Adjustment Calculations for Feed Fed
Pond Conversion Ratio Calculations
Additional InformationThere are four other volumes in the "Technology Transfer Series: Aquaculture in Dredged Material Containment Areas," published by the Mississippi State University Extension Service and the Mississippi-Alabama Sea Grant Program. One, the "Containment Area Aquaculture Handbook" reviews all of the important aspects to consider when planning a DMCA aquaculture venture. The remaining volumes cover planning, design, and construction of facilities, economics and legal considerations in DMCA aquaculture. Please refer to these publications if you intend to pursue DMCA aquaculture further. An extensive library of aquaculture publications can help you in deciding on species choices, management options and other factors. Contact your state Cooperative Extension Service or the Sea Grant College Program for assistance in locating these publications. Ask for publications of the USDA Regional Aquaculture Centers in your area. By Jurij Homziak, Extension Marine Resources Specialist, and C. David Veal, Head, Coastal Research and Extension Center. Published by Information Services Department, Division of Agriculture, Forestry, and Veterinary Medicine. Mississippi State University does not discriminate on the basis of race, color, religion, national origin, sex, age, disability, or veteran status. Publication
1814 Copyright by Mississippi State University. All rights reserved. This document may be copied and distributed for nonprofit educational purposes provided that credit is given to the Mississippi State University Extension Service. |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Visit: DAFVM || USDA Search our Site || Need more information about this subject? Last Modified: Tuesday, 11-Dec-07 11:38:02 URL: http://msucares.com/pubs/publications/p1814.htm Mississippi State University is an equal opportunity institution. Recommendations on this web site do not endorse any commercial products or trade names. |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||